Hello Guys:
I apologize for interrupting your discussion but thought it would be best if I personally respond to many of the questions you have been debating. Also, please pardon my use of English. I am embarrassed to admit that I do not know your beautiful language.
I'd also like to say that I appreciate the topic you have been discussing. I'm not surprised to read some of the posts and congratulate you for maintaining a friendly, respectful attitude towards each other!
To fully understand the image I produced of M63, you need to know a little bit about my image processing philosophy. There are two broad groups of astro-photographers. 1)Those that produce images to help science and 2) those that create art.
I consider myself to be an artist. I have never claimed to be a scientist nor did I set out to join a scientific research team. I fell into this situation by accident but am grateful that for what it has taught me and enjoy working with professional astronomers.
If you click on the following link, my web site page with M63 will be returned.
http://www.cosmotography.com/images/small_ngc5055.html
If you mouse over the image, you will see an inverted picture. This inverted image was produced for science. The color inset was requested by my team's Principal Investigator so that viewers would have a reference.
This image was produced with minimal processing. For instance, the final master luminance channel was linear-stretched. That means, I used the Photoshop levels tool. I did not use the curves tool. From a scientific perspective, this image was valuable for our research into the nature of the stream.
However, the inverted image is not attractive unless you are a dedicated researcher. So, I also produced an artistic version of the image using the same data.
The full color image of M63 with the stream is a work of art. It was highly processed using Photoshop. Many things in this image are exaggerated to make the picture more appealing to the general public because I have found that people outside our hobby like deep space images with a lot of contrast and color.
So, the colors in this picture are very saturated, the size of the brighter stars are reduced, the diffraction spikes around several stars are overly bright and the difference between the brightest and dimmest parts of the picture has been adjusted. In short, the full color image is not scientifically accurate. It is my personal interpretation.
We have to remember that we destroy the scientific value of our data anytime we apply a non-linear stretch, use DDP, deconvolution, smoothing or sharpening tools. That means most astro-photography images are artistic renderings and when it comes to art, beauty is subjective. It is in the eye of the beholder.
Processing an image is like walking through a maze that has more than one path to the exit. As we proceed through the maze, we make processing decisions that take us in a new direction. Each processing decision we make is cumulative- each choice affects the next decision for better or worse.
This is one reason beginners have trouble with image processing. It is easy to get lost inside the image processing maze. This is also why images of the same subject look different when they are produced by two different astro-photographers. Each astro-photographer makes different processing decisions and therefore takes different paths through the maze.
So, some of the issues you have been discussing are connected to the way I processed the picture. For example:
1) I over-saturated the color of the stream so its hue would seen. The color is based on my data and our research proved the hue is correct because the stream is composed of old, red stars that are too far away to be resolved.
2) The brightest stars were too large in my data, so I reduced their size using the Photoshop pinch tool. I did this so the bright stars would not distract attention from the tidal stream. This was a aesthetic decision that you may or may not agree with.
3) Normally, star size indicates brightness. Since I chose to reduce the size of the brightest stars, I decided to let the diffraction spikes indicate their brightness. So, the diffraction spikes would appear normal if the stars were their original size. This was also an artistic decision that you may or may not agree with. It should also be noted that I do not add artificial diffraction spikes to my pictures. They say a picture is worth a thousand words, well diffraction spikes are my way of adding punctuation. I like diffraction spikes and I spend a lot of time working on them in a separate Photoshop layer.
4) Since this is an artistic picture, I processed it selectively. I have been selectively processing my images for many years. Selective processing is not new. Many people do this. For example, the Photoshop magic wand tool, the Color range tool or lasso tool are selective processing methods. If you remove an artifact from your images, like a cosmic ray, you are selectively processing. I use the Photoshop paint brush to selectively blend layers and create my final image.
5) I do not add artificial color to my images. All the color comes from the exposures I take. I use the Photoshop vibrance tool, soft light layers and Lab color mode to saturate my pictures. I also use the color balance tool to selectively adjust the hues.
You also noticed that I was able to reveal the stream with less exposure time than other images. I suspect this is due to the flat field image I used. These streams are very, very faint. They also have a low surface brightness. So, if your background is not flat, you will not see the streams regardless of your total exposure length.
I have tried several methods for taking flats and found the best is to take dawn sky flats with my telescope aimed at the sky's null point. Your results may be different, of course. Regardless, I suspect the other images you compared to mine were produced with a poor flat.
In closing, let me add that my processing techniques are consistent with those used by the Hubble Space Telescope Institute and many other large observatories. If you have time, I suggest you download and read the following paper written by Dr. Travis Rector, a famous professional astronomer. It provides several methods for processing narrow band images and it explains why artistic images are important to make astronomical pictures appealing to the general public:
http://astro.berkeley.edu/~kalas/disksi ... tor07a.pdf
I hope this explains many of the questions you have been discussing. I apologize for the length of my response but you had a lot of questions! I sincerely appreciate the opportunity to join your conversation.
I also appreciate your kind words and compliments! Thank you very much!!!
Please feel free to email me if you have other questions, suggestions or comments at
rj2010@comcast.net
I hope each of you have a great rest of the week!
Jay